The Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander both fit into the mid-size crossover SUV category, delivering a helpful combination of cargo space, technology, power, and comfort. Whether you’re looking for a spacious SUV for family outings or a stylish and capable work vehicle for business, the Pilot and Highlander are two strong options. See the pros and cons of the Honda Pilot vs. Toyota Highlander in this helpful comparison guide.
What Are the Main Differences With a Honda Pilot Vs. a Toyota Highlander?
To give you the down low on Pilot and Highlander specs, we reviewed a range of model years, including shiny 2023s and 2024s, more recent 2020s, and older 2013s to 2017s. Here are a few highlights to keep in mind when comparing the two makes and models:
- The Toyota Highlander usually offers a smoother and quieter ride than the Pilot.
- Many Honda Pilot models offer more cargo space and roomier third-row seating.
- The base 2023 Highlander gets 21/28 mpg compared to 19/27 mpg for the Pilot.
- From 2023 forward, the Highlander has an optional hybrid engine with a significant jump (36/35 mpg for city/highway) in fuel economy.
- Newer Highlanders switch to a turbocharged 2.4-liter four-cylinder instead of the Pilot’s classic 3-5 liter V-6.
- The 2024 Highlander starts at $39,000 and the 2024 Pilot starts at $37,000.
- Both Honda and Toyota offer a manufacturer warranty with two years of complimentary maintenance.
At a glance, the Pilot wins in terms of raw space and cabin size, but the Highlander offers more luxury and comfort overall. Toyota also enjoys a stellar reputation for quality, safety, and long-term performance, which may sway fans of the brand.
Which Is More Reliable — the Toyota Highlander or the Honda Pilot?
Reliability ratings can vary significantly by model year. Check out a few year-on-year comparison scores for dependability:
- 2024: Pilot (80/100) — Highlander (79/100)
- 2023: Pilot (80/100) — Highlander (79/100)
- 2020: Highlander (86/100) — Pilot (71/100)
- 2015: Highlander (80/100) — Pilot (79/100)
- 2009: Highlander (84/100) — Pilot (74/100)
Based on these ratings from trusted industry veterans such as J.D. Power, we have to give the Toyota Highlander the overall win in quality, customer satisfaction, and reliability. That said, the Pilot’s 2023 redesign went a long way to strengthen its reputation for high-quality parts.
Which Is Quieter — Highlander or Pilot?
The answer to this question depends on the model year. After the 2023 redesign, the Pilot pulls off a quieter ride overall. For older model years, though, the Highlander comes out ahead nearly every time. The Highlander also scores points for its firm but comfortable seating.
What Are the Best and Worst Model Years for the Toyota Highlander?
From 2018 onward, the Highlander enjoys relatively few consumer complaints. Older models generally perform well, but there are a few outliers to watch for:
- Fuel pump recall: The 2017-2019 model had engine stalling problems because of a faulty fuel pump, leading to a 1,525,000-vehicle recall.
- Transmission failure: Some owners of 2017 models reported major transmission problems at under 50,000 miles.
- Tech troubles and interior issues: The 2015 Highlander takes the prize for the highest number of owner complaints, but these are mainly for interior audio issues and uncomfortable seating. There was also a 110,000-vehicle recall for potential loss of power steering because of water filtration and ECU damage.
- Drivetrain problems: While most Highlanders performed well in this area, the 2008 and 2003 model years had serious engine issues, from broken oil lines and damaged seals to knocking and complete engine bolt failure. The 2003 first-gen model can require total engine replacement after just 125,000 miles on average.
Toyota responds quickly when problems are discovered; other model years in the same generation typically fare well in terms of reliability. Repair data and owner reviews praise the Highlander’s low repair costs (about $490 on average) and overall dependability rating (4.0/5.0 stars).
What Are the Most and Least Reliable Honda Pilot Models?
For the majority of model years, the Honda Pilot enjoys few owner complaints, and most repairs are for minor issues when they appear. That said, some years stand out because of serious drivetrain problems at around 100,000 miles, just when the manufacturer warranty is set to expire.
- 2003: The 2003 Pilot had 14 separate recalls, including for potentially explosive airbags, transmission gear failures, and ignition switch failures. The affected transmissions usually required complete replacement.
- 2009 to 2010: These two model years saw a spike in complaints for excessive oil consumption, spark plug damage, and variable cylinder management system problems that require a mechanic to correct. The repair costs for these related issues exceed $3,000 on average.
- 2016: The 2016 pilot has a surprisingly high number of transmission, electrical, engine, and fuel system problems, especially considering that it hasn’t reached the 10-year mark yet. These problems don’t usually require system replacement, but they affect keyless start, drive performance, and fuel injector operation (at 60,000 miles), potentially leading to more serious problems down the road.
Repair costs are slightly higher for the Pilot at about $550. On average, owners need to visit the dealership slightly more often than other mid-size SUVs.
Which Is Right for You: Toyota Highlander or Honda Pilot?
Our key takeaways in the battle of Toyota Highlander vs. Honda Pilot come down to your lifestyle and space needs. For business, you may prefer the luxury of the Highlander or want the extra cargo space of the Pilot. The Highlander wins in terms of family comfort, but if you have kids, pets, soccer gear, groceries, and suitcases to haul, your main concern may be how well everything fits. In that case, a newer Pilot is perfect.
Find Dependable Vehicle Protection Plans for Your Honda Pilot or Toyota Highlander
Aside from some poor model years, both the Highlander and Pilot deliver good reliability, low repair costs, easy access to parts, and solid resale value. In other words, they’re good investments as daily driving vehicles for individuals and families. Discover how a vehicle protection plan can make your life easier as you aim for 100,000 miles and beyond. Contact us to compare VPP costs for Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander model years.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Which is more reliable — the Honda Pilot or Toyota Highlander?
A: Reliability varies by year, but overall, the Toyota Highlander scores slightly higher in long-term dependability. J.D. Power ratings give the Highlander higher marks in most model years, including 2020 (86/100 vs. the Pilot’s 71/100). However, the redesigned 2023-2024 Pilot shows strong improvement in quality and materials.
Q: Which SUV has more cargo space and interior room?
A: The Honda Pilot generally offers more interior volume, including a roomier third-row and extra cargo capacity behind the rear seats. Families that need space for kids, pets, and luggage may find the Pilot a better fit.
Q: Does the Toyota Highlander get better gas mileage than the Pilot?
A: Yes. The Highlander’s turbocharged four-cylinder engine and hybrid option deliver stronger fuel efficiency. The 2023 Highlander Hybrid achieves around 36/35 mpg (city/highway), compared to 19/27 mpg for the Pilot’s V-6.
Q: Which is quieter and more comfortable — Highlander or Pilot?
A: In older model years, the Highlander is known for its quiet cabin and smooth ride. After the 2023 redesign, the Pilot has caught up, providing improved sound insulation and a refined driving experience.
Q: What are the best and worst Toyota Highlander model years?
A: The 2018 and newer Highlanders earn high marks for reliability. Avoid 2015–2017 models, which had fuel pump recalls, transmission issues, and interior complaints. The 2003 first-generation Highlander is known for engine bolt failures and should be approached cautiously.
Q: What are the most and least reliable Honda Pilot model years?
A: The 2013–2015 and 2023+ Pilots are solid performers. Be cautious with 2003, 2009–2010, and 2016 models, which have been linked to transmission, oil consumption, and electrical issues.
Q: Which SUV offers better value overall?
A: Both are excellent mid-size SUVs, but the choice depends on your needs. The Highlander provides better fuel efficiency and comfort, while the Pilot offers more cargo room and flexibility. Both hold strong resale value and respond well to a vehicle protection plan.
