The midsize truck segment is surging in popularity, offering a blend of practicality, capability, and everyday drivability. The Chevy Colorado and the Toyota Tacoma are two midsize trucks that stand out in the marketplace. Both vehicles have a reputation as rugged and reliable contenders, but how do you choose which vehicle is more suitable for your lifestyle?

When considering the Chevy Colorado vs. the Toyota Tacoma, it is important to understand the nuances that set these vehicles apart. Explore each midsize truck in a side-by-side comparison to understand which truck aligns with your needs.

Comparing the Chevy Colorado vs. Toyota Tacoma

While both midsize trucks have potential, each has specific inclusions and upgrades that better suit your needs. By reviewing the engines, off-road capabilities, comfort, and reliability, you should find it easier to choose between the Colorado and the Tacoma.

Performance and Powertrains

Toyota Tacoma vs. Chevy Colorado

Most truck enthusiasts believe the most important part of any truck lies in how much power it has under the hood and how they can use it. After upgrading the Colorado in 2023, Chevy now boasts a 2.7L turbocharged four-cylinder engine in the model across various trim packages. Depending on the tuning, the Colorado can go from work-focused, with an output of 237 horsepower and 259 lb-ft of torque, to a performance setup, with 310 horsepower and 430 lb-ft of torque.

The 2024 Toyota Tacoma offers a 2.4L turbocharged four-cylinder engine as its standard offering. The engine produces 278 horsepower and 317 lb-ft of torque, which places the truck between the Colorado’s offerings.

Regarding towing and payload capacity, the Chevy has a maximum towing capacity of 7,700 lbs when properly equipped. The Tacoma has a maximum towing capacity of 6,800 lbs.

Based on performance and powertrain alone, the trucks are comparable, with no clear winner in the Chevy Colorado vs. Toyota Tacoma debate. However, if you often tow at capacity and in excess of 7,000 lbs, you may prefer the Colorado, particularly the more robust packages.

Off-Road Capability

Are you the off-roading type? Colorado and Tacoma excel in off-road capabilities, but each brand takes a unique approach. The Chevy offers two trim options for off-roading: Z71 and ZR2. The Z71 provides an upgraded suspension with locking differentials and skid plates. Chevy’s ZR2 takes things up a notch with Multimatic’s spool-valve dampers, increased ground clearance, and more aggressive approach and departure angles.

The Tacoma also offers two off-road trim packages: TRD Off-Road and TRD Pro. Tacoma’s TRD Off-Road features electronic, locking differentials, Bilstein shocks, skid plates, and Crawl Control and Multi-Select Terrain Select systems for enhanced terrain management. The TRD Pro includes Fox internal bypass shocks, additional lift for 9.4 inches of ground clearance, a TRD-specific cat-back exhaust, and exclusive styling.

The right truck for you in the off-roading category depends on your preferences. The Colorado ZR2 is an excellent option for high-speed desert running, rock crawling, and other daunting obstacles. The Tacoma TRD Pro is more flexible, excelling in mud, rocks, and on trails — better suited to adventurous overlanding.

Interior Features and Technology

You can’t forget the comfort factor when comparing the Chevy Colorado vs. the Toyota Tacoma. While both trucks are reliable workhorses, they include the premium comfort and feature-rich designs of most modern vehicles.

The Colorado may have a leather or fabric interior, depending on the trim selection. The newer model boasts a redesigned interior, emphasizing a modern and user-friendly design. Its beautiful interior centers around the 11.3-inch touchscreen infotainment system with Google compatibility.

While the Tacoma has changed little in recent designs, it still uses functional and durable materials and offers leather-trimmed options in higher trim packages. Current truck models have display screens up to 8 inches. Upgrades can also include the JBL premium sound system and an in-bed power outlet.

Despite some subtle differences, both trucks have standard, robust safety features. Every Colorado comes with the Chevy Safety Assist suite, and every Tacoma includes a Safety Sense package. Also, you can upgrade both trucks with features like blind-spot monitoring, rear cross-traffic alert, and a surround-view camera system.

Ownership and Reliability

A woman decides between a Chevy Colorado vs. Toyota Tacoma.

You shouldn’t base your Chevy Colorado vs. Toyota Tacoma decision on the initial specs alone. It is essential to consider the reliability and value of long-term ownership. Both trucks are reliable long-term vehicles lasting about 200,000-300,000 miles with proper care and maintenance.

However, when it comes to the Toyota Tacoma vs. Chevy Colorado, it’s important to know the Tacoma often surpasses the Colorado in resale price. The brand’s reputation for reliability includes the Tacoma, and it consistently scores well in surveys by J.D. Power and Consumer Reports.

Both vehicles also provide an industry-standard bumper-to-bumper warranty of three years or 36,000 miles and a powertrain warranty of five years or 60,000 miles. Toyota also offers two years or 25,000 miles of complimentary maintenance through ToyotaCare. Beyond their standard warranties, you can purchase a vehicle protection plan.

Price Points

The 2024 Chevy Colorado has a starting price of $31,095. The top-tier ZR2 and ZR2 Bison models are $48,395 and $60,540 respectively.

The 2024 Toyota Tacoma has a starting price of $32,995, slightly more than the base Colorado. However, the top-tier TRD Off-Road and Limited are $43,295 and $53,595 respectively.

Which is Better: Chevy Colorado or Toyota Tacoma?

While you came here looking for an answer to which vehicle wins the Chevy Colorado vs. the Toyota Tacoma showdown, there is no one-size-fits-all answer. The right choice depends on what you want and need from a midsize truck. That said, the Colorado and Tacoma are exceptional and capable trucks that are solidly built and dependable. The Colorado might edge out the Tacoma regarding the powertrain, interior upgrades, and possible starting price, but the Tacoma might do the same regarding off-road prowess, reliability, and resale value.

Each midsize truck is capable and built to last. You can’t go wrong with either option. If you plan on keeping the truck for the long haul, you want to protect yourself when the warranty runs out. A vehicle protection plan from autopom! can help protect your wallet once the standard warranty expires. Check out our pricing options for more information.